The ladies reign when it comes to the Song Association scoreboard... but can Darren Criss change that? The award-winning Glee alum stopped by — with his guitar in tow — for our first-ever, instrument-accompanied version of the game. Watch as he sings The Killers, The Beatles, and Fall Out Boy, all while strumming a (broken!) guitar.

SUBSCRIBE to ELLE http://bit.ly/SubscribeToELLE