Before the song, Finn and Rachel have a conversation in which Finn tells Rachel that he knows she cannot commit with Brody properly because she still loves him. They seem as if they are about to kiss but Rachel tells him they have to sing their duet. The song starts when Rachel takes the last flower petal. Jake, Marley, Kurt, and Blaine can be seen slow dancing with each other while Finn and Rachel take to the stage as they sing. Sue is seen watching everyone slow dance sadly when a man asks her to dance. Quinn, Santana, Brittany, Sam, Betty, and Artie can also be seen enjoying themselves and dancing. Quinn comments that she had never slow-danced with a girl before but that she likes it, leaving Santana with a smile. Rachel and Finn hold hands as they sing and the scene cuts to show them holding hands walking into their hotel room together. Blaine and Kurt sing as Kurt drags Blaine by the tie into their room, Marley and Jake sing as they walk in to their room together, happily. Quinn and Santana laugh and enjoy themselves as they sing, running to their room, and Betty and Artie go together, seeming to have created a new friendship. In the hotel room, Finn and Rachel take off their clothes, eagerly.

Lyrics:
Finn:
I know it's late
I know you're weary
I know your plans don't include me

Rachel:
Still here we are
Both of us lonely
Longing for shelter from all that we see

Finn:
Why should we worry?
No one will care, girl

Rachel:
Look at the stars now, so far away
We've got tonight
Who needs tomorrow?
We've got tonight, babe
Why don't you stay?

Deep in my soul
I've been so lonely
All of my hopes so fading away
And I've longed for love

Like everyone else does
I know I'll keep searching after today

Finn:
So there it is, girl
We've got it all now

Rachel:
And here we are, babe
What do you say?

Finn and Rachel:
We've got tonight
Who needs tomorrow?
We've got tonight, babe
Why don't we stay?

Kurt:
I know it's late and I know you're weary

Blaine:
I know your plans don't include me

Marley:
Still here we are

Jake and Marley:
Both of us lonely
Both of us lonely

Quinn:
We've got tonight

Santana:
Who needs tomorrow?

Artie:
Let's make it last

Betty:
Let's find a way

Finn:
Turn out the light

Rachel:
Oh, come take my hand now

Finn and Rachel:
We've got tonight, babe
Why don't we stay?
We've got tonight, babe
Why don't we stay?